Senior Manager pf Individual Giving
Organization Background
Young Judaea is a diverse community that educates and empowers Jewish youth to deeply engage with Israel and to lead positive change for the Jewish People, Israel and the World. For over 115 years, Young Judaea has inspired Jewish youth of diverse backgrounds to become engaged leaders and inspired activists with a deep personal connection to Israel. Young Judaea does this through a robust arc of programs that include summer camps, year-round programming, Israel immersive travel experiences, and alumni gatherings. For more information, please visit www.youngjudaea.org.
Position Summary
Young Judaea Global seeks a strategic, relationship-oriented, and highly organized Senior Manager, Individual Giving to lead the organization’s annual individual giving program and strengthen its pipeline of current and prospective donors. Reporting to the CEO, the Senior Manager will be responsible for the strategy and execution of Young Judaea Global’s annual giving program, including donor acquisition, retention, upgrades, re-engagement, stewardship, and pipeline development.
The Senior Manager will oversee the annual campaign calendar and donor segmentation strategy, manage a portfolio of annual and mid-level donors, and identify opportunities to deepen philanthropic engagement among alumni, parents, and other members of the Young Judaea community. The Senior Manager will also serve as a key partner to the CEO in major donor cultivation and stewardship by supporting donor research, moves management, meeting preparation, follow-up, and stewardship strategy.
The Senior Manager will supervise the Alumni Engagement Associate and serve as a central point of coordination across the development function, working closely with the Grants Manager, Office Administrator, finance, communications, and program staff to maintain an integrated fundraising calendar, monitor progress, and ensure fundraising priorities translate into clear staff action.
This is a full-time position based in New York City with a hybrid work schedule.
Key ResponsibilitiesAnnual Giving Strategy & Campaign Management
● Develop and execute a comprehensive annual individual giving strategy in partnership with the CEO.
● Create and manage the annual fundraising calendar, including direct mail, email campaigns, year-end giving, Giving Tuesday, targeted appeals, and other annual giving initiatives.
● Develop donor segmentation strategies based on giving history, engagement, affinity, and potential.
● Partner with communications staff to develop compelling donor messaging, appeals, stewardship communications, and campaign materials.
● Develop strategies to increase donor acquisition, retention, renewal, upgrades, recurring giving, and re-engagement.
● Monitor campaign performance and adjust strategies based on results and donor behavior.
● Coordinate individual giving initiatives with broader organizational communications and program priorities.
Donor Portfolio & Pipeline Management
● Manage a portfolio of annual and mid-level individual donors and prospects.
● Develop cultivation, solicitation, and stewardship strategies appropriate to different donor segments.
● Identify donors with the potential to increase their philanthropic investment in Young Judaea.
● Develop and implement strategies to upgrade donors and move qualified prospects into the major donor pipeline.
● Identify and re-engage lapsed and under-engaged donors.
● Maintain clear next steps and moves-management plans for priority donors and prospects.
● Partner with the Alumni Engagement Associate to identify alumni with philanthropic potential and create pathways from engagement to giving.
● Work with program and movement colleagues to identify parents, alumni, volunteers, and other community members with potential for deeper engagement.
CEO & Major Donor Support
● Serve as the primary staff partner supporting the CEO’s major donor portfolio.
● Prepare donor and prospect briefings, including giving history, engagement history, interests, connections, and recommended next steps.
● Maintain moves-management plans and ensure timely follow-up after donor meetings and conversations.
● Prepare donor proposals, stewardship materials, impact updates, and other individualized communications in partnership with appropriate staff.
● Coordinate cultivation and stewardship opportunities for CEO-managed donors and prospects.
● Track CEO-related donor activity and ensure that agreed-upon follow-up actions are completed.
● Identify donors and prospects who should transition into direct CEO cultivation.
Donor Stewardship & Engagement
● Develop and maintain a coordinated stewardship plan for annual and mid-level donors.
● Ensure donors receive timely, meaningful acknowledgment and engagement throughout the year.
● Identify opportunities to connect donors with Young Judaea programs, leaders, participants, alumni, and impact stories.
● Develop strategies to recognize donor loyalty, milestones, increased giving, and long-term support.
● Coordinate donor-focused events, briefings, small gatherings, and engagement opportunities as appropriate.
● Work closely with program and communications staff to ensure donor stewardship reflects the full scope and impact of Young Judaea’s work.
Alumni Engagement & Philanthropic Pipeline
● Supervise and support the Alumni Engagement Associate.
● Partner with the Alumni Engagement Associate to connect alumni engagement activities with long-term philanthropic development.
● Develop strategies to identify and cultivate alumni as donors, volunteers, ambassadors, and future leaders.
● Create clear pathways for alumni moving from event participation and community engagement into philanthropic support.
● Collaborate with the Alumni Engagement Associate on donor-focused follow-up from reunions, missions, regional events, and other alumni initiatives.
Volunteer Fundraising & Development Committee
● Support the CEO and board leadership in engaging volunteers in fundraising and donor outreach.
● Coordinate the work of the Development Committee or other volunteer fundraising structures.
● Provide volunteers with appropriate donor lists, outreach tools, talking points, and follow-up support.
● Track volunteer outreach and ensure accountability for agreed-upon fundraising actions.
● Identify opportunities to expand the network of individuals involved in advancing Young Judaea’s philanthropic goals.
Data, Reporting & Fundraising Analytics
● Maintain a clear and accurate individual giving pipeline and moves-management system.
● Monitor individual giving revenue against annual goals and projections.
● Produce regular reports for the CEO and senior leadership on revenue, donor retention, upgrades, acquisition, pipeline activity, and campaign performance.
● Analyze giving trends and donor behavior to inform fundraising strategy.
● Work closely with the Office Administrator to ensure accurate donor records, gift information, acknowledgments, and Salesforce data.
Development Coordination & Fundraising Management
● Coordinate with the Grants Manager, Alumni Engagement Associate, Office Administrator, finance, communications, and program staff to align fundraising activity, timing, messaging, and shared priorities.
● Maintain an integrated development calendar encompassing individual giving, institutional fundraising, donor stewardship, campaigns, major donor follow-up, and volunteer fundraising activity.
● Partner with finance and senior leadership to maintain accurate fundraising revenue forecasts, identify gaps or risks, and support reconciliation of fundraising revenue.
● Monitor fundraising progress across revenue streams and provide the CEO with a clear, consolidated view of performance against goals.
● Surface fundraising risks, opportunities, upcoming decisions, and priority actions for the CEO and senior leadership.
● Translate CEO and board fundraising priorities into clear staff responsibilities, timelines, and follow-up actions.
Qualifications
● Bachelor’s degree or equivalent professional experience.
● 4–6 years of progressive nonprofit fundraising, annual giving, donor engagement, or related development experience.
● Demonstrated experience managing annual giving campaigns and individual donor relationships.
● Strong understanding of donor cultivation, solicitation, stewardship, retention, and moves management.
● Strong project management skills with the ability to manage multiple campaigns, donor relationships, and deadlines simultaneously.
● Excellent written and verbal communication skills.
● Strong interpersonal and relationship-building skills.
● Ability to work effectively with senior leadership, board members, volunteers, donors, and colleagues across departments.
● Comfort working with donor databases and using fundraising data to inform strategy and decision-making.
● Supervisory experience or demonstrated ability to coach and support junior staff.
Preferred Qualifications
● Experience in the Jewish communal sector, youth movements, camps, education, Israel engagement, or nonprofit organizations.
● Familiarity with Young Judaea and its programs, community, or alumni network.
● Experience with Salesforce or comparable donor management systems.
● Experience managing mid-level giving programs or moving annual donors into major gift pipelines.
● Experience supporting executive-level major donor cultivation and stewardship.
● Experience working with volunteer fundraising committees or boards.
● Experience developing donor segmentation, retention, and re-engagement strategies.
Compensation
Salary Range: $90,000–$105,000 commensurate with experience.
Send a cover letter and CV to adina@youngjudaea.org to apply for this position.